By:
Matt Rowan
4/30/08
2008 Redskins Draft Review
As the NFL draft drew closer many of us
in Redskins nation were once again thrown into agony as the news
came out that Cincinnati had been offered “multiple 1st round picks”
for Chad Johnson. It seems the last sentence of my last article was
eerily prophetic, thankfully the only front office with less logic
then the Skins is the Bengals, and the offer was rejected.
Instead the team surprised us all, for
once they were unusually shrewd trading the #21 overall pick to the
Falcons in turn for two 2nd rounders. Vinny, Dan, and the gang had
spent a lot of time on creating a board, which they faithfully were
loyal to on draft day, leading to some questionable decisions.
The Picks
-2 (34) WR Devin Thomas, Michigan
State- The top ranked WR in the draft would’ve been a nice
selection at #21 but like manna from heaven he fell on the Redskins
in the second round. Yes he really only had one good year at
Michigan State, but that was enough to showcase his talent and
potential. Being a tall (6’2) receiver, Thomas fits Zorns west coast
protocol. He has exceptional athletic ability and is especially
dynamic after the catch and excels at bringing down passes over his
head.
Grade: A
I would’ve preferred James Hardy, but
both are talented. Excellent trade. Excellent Pick.
-2 (48) TE Fred Davis, USC- Davis
is athletic with great quickness and route running ability, and a
sure pair of hands to compliment. However he does not overwhelm with
his speed, size, or blocking but is solid all around. He will be
used opposite Cooley in Zorns 2 tight-end packages.
Grade: C
This pick came as a little bit of a
shock as big DE Calais Campbell was there for the picking to provide
much needed support on the Dline.
-2 (51) WR Malcolm Kelly, Oklahoma-
Kelly was originally regarded as the top available WR in the
draft. However concerns over his health and a poor combine dropped
his value. He has had thigh injuries as well as meniscus surgery
(knee). Kelly will rarely blow teams away with his speed, however he
is a very smooth and fluid runner. He possesses great size (6’4,
225) and is muscular and knows how to use both to his advantage, he
also has exceptional hands. He will act as the redzone big target
that has been much needed for years.
Grade: A
Although I worry about his knees
(Michael Westbrook??) I love this pick. Redskins are now loaded with
WR targets and hopefully will not have to address that position for
years. Zorn is now set to begin teaching.
-3 (96) OG Chad Rinehart,
Northern Iowa- Rinehart (6’5, 320) started at LT in college, but
will be used on the interior for the Skins. He is massive and
powerfully built and displays adequate quickness off the line with
the ability to open gaping holes. When on top of his game he is a
ferocious and intimidating blocker. He will eventually work his way
into the starting lineup and replace Pete Kendall.
Grade: A
Great to see the Skins bring in a “Hog”.
He needs to work on his blocking technique, but Joe Bugel is the
best there is when it comes to grooming lineman. Let’s hope Rinehart
starts sooner rather than later.
-4 (124) CB Justin Tryon, Arizona
State- Tryon is a hard-nosed little CB that loves to play close
to the defender and jam at the line. However he’s limited in size
(5’9, 190) and may have to change his approach in the NFL.
Grade: B
With Springs and Smoot aging, and Rogers
coming off major knee surgery, CB needed to be addressed. Tryons
fire and never back down attitude reminds me a little of Smoot, and
it will be fun watching him find his place on the team.
-6 (168) P Durant Brooks, Georgia
Tech- Brooks is the winner of the Ray Guy award for best punter
in the nation. He is very confident and showcases a healthy blend of
power and touch.
Grade: C
With the DLine still not addressed. 6th
round seemed a little high to be picking a punter, although it has
also become a need position.
-6 (180) Kareem Moore, Nicholls
State- Moore is a hardnosed safety that works hard and tackles
well. He’s stout but at 5’10 is a little on the short side. Although
he plays quick Moore is not a very fast safety.
Grade: C
With the loss of Sean Taylor safety was
a position that needed to be addressed. This still leaves questions
as to whether or not Laron Landry will remain at free safety or move
back to strong.
-6 (186) QB Colt Brennan, Hawaii-
It has been said many times that Brennan is a “system qb” that
played in a spread system... major knocks on a college qb. However
Colt is a qb that plays with confidence and accuracy to throw the
ball into tight spots. He’s a tough qb as far as playing through
pain, and has the ability to escape and even scramble if necessary.
He’s a bit structurally frail and is coming off a hip surgery, which
may keep him out for the start of the year. Unlike Jason Campbell,
Brennan is undersized (6’2, 207) and although accurate, has below
average arm strength.
Grade: B
I kind of like this pick. Zorn will have
a young qb to groom in his offense as well as backup Campbell in the
future... And who knows, maybe give him a little push??
-7 (242) DE Rob Jackson, Kansas
State- Jackson is explosive, but a pass rusher and a pass rusher
only.
Grade: C
Sure, yeah. We needed help on the Dline
especially with the pass rush. Kinda sad to see it addressed so
late. For that reason only, I gave it a C.
-7 (249) S Christopher Horton, UCLA-
Horton is a high IQ type of Defensive Back. He rarely gets
caught out of position and works hard on all aspects of the
position. He is however limited athletically in both speed and
strength.
Grade: B
Good to see the team bring in another
option to compete at safety.
My Opinion:
Although the draft style seemed at bit
unorthodox, I like the end result for the most part.
Although more depth may need to be added
on the O-line, the Redskins have set up their offense. Zorn now has
all the pieces in place. In Jason Campbell he has a groom able QB
with all the physical tools. Throw in a solid veteran Oline, veteran
playmakers (Moss, Portis, Cooley), and now toss in three rookie pass
catchers with large upsides. It will be very exciting to watch them
grow, let’s hope that Snyder gives Zorn the time and space to make
it happen.
Defensive line was not addressed and
that is concerning, very concerning. Last year Andre Carter was the
lone every down lineman that can disrupt that backfield and put
pressure on the QB. They will need to step up as a unit in order to
improve on that next year.
Overall Draft Grade: B
Remaining Options:
DE Tommy Blake, TCU- Would love to
see the Skins bring this kid in for a look. If Blake had come out
his Jr. year, he would’ve been one of the first DEs selected. He
excels as both a pass rusher and run stopper. Plays ferociously and
will get into the backfield often.
The knock on him is his mental
stability. He missed a lot of his sr. year while recovering from
depression. He is a good guy and possesses a deep Christian faith,
and if successfully treated, could be a major steal if signed.
DE Darrell Robertson, Georgia Tech-
Kind of surprised he didn’t get drafted. Like Rob Jackson he’s
undersized but a good pass rusher, may be worth a look.
4
/21/08
2008 Redskins Off-season and Draft
Preview
Hail to the Redskins! Hail Free
Agency!
Not this year, all is eerily quiet in Redskins land. Browse the
internet, take a look at the Skins forums, listen to sports radio.
Media outlets revolving around the Burgundy & Gold strangely are not
buzzing with news of the latest free agent touching down in DC.
Instead they’re filled with speculation and guessing at what Snyder,
Cerrato, and more importantly Jim Zorn are planning.
Redskins big and only “splash” this year
so far... Jerome Mathis WR/KR from the Houston Texans. Mathis
has world class speed and went to the pro-bowl as a KR in 2005 where
he averaged 28.6 yards a return. Mathis has since been injury prone
and hasn’t equaled that success. Mathis seems to be an anti-Gibbs
pickup in a sense that he has a troubled past, he was arrested for
assaulting his girlfriend in February, although charges were
dropped..
It is unclear as how he will be used as a Redskin. Rock Cartwright
had success as primary KR, and Randle El has been the PR since
joining the team. Randle Els numbers have dropped considerably
though, and it may be time for a move.
Draft
This year the Redskins have 9 picks
Round 1 (21), 2 (51), 3, 3, 5, 6, 7, 7, 7.
Most Redskins fans are bracing for the
inevitable trade of draft picks, remember dealing a 3rd round pick
for TJ Ducketts 38 handoffs??? Fortunately Jim Zorn seems to have a
brought a quiet sense of stability to the team. He’s satisfied with
his veteran playoff roster, and is looking to fill in the holes and
bring in depth through the draft. It’s a timely much needed shift in
thinking, and the team actually has the picks this year to back it
up.
Look for the Redskins to first address
D-Line and WR in pursuit of a pass rusher and a tall pass catcher.
Also with the current O-Line and CBs aging, they will be a priority
throughout the draft. Redskins will select a QB (yes qb) in the mid
to late rounds.
Possible Early Round Selections
1. Philip Merling DE, Clemson -
Merling plays with a high motor and was a dominant force throughout
his college career. He plays fundamentally sound and is above
average athletically. Bulking up his upper body might be a possible
need, but with his frame it shouldn’t be a problem.
2. Calais Campbell, DE Miami -
Many teams seem to be intrigued by Campbell's size. At 6’7 the
debate rages whether it will be a strength or a hindrance once he
reaches the professional level.
3. James Hardy, WR Indiana -
Hardy has been my favorite WR in the draft since day one, and he’s
moving up boards quickly. He’s 6’5+ and runs fluidly with good
speed. If he can learn to be more disciplined with his route
running, he could be a dominant WR and the redzone target the Skins
have been needing for years.
4. Jordy Nelson, WR Kansas State -
Jordy will probably go in the mid to late 2nd round. He’s a WR
that’s easy to like. He’s built powerfully and makes the tough over
the middle catches. He would compliment Campbell greatly on blown
impromptu plays as his size (6’2) and knack for finding soft spots
in the secondary would come in very handy.
5. Branden Albert, G/T-Virginia -
The Skins would be very luck to land Albert at #21 as he will
probably go in the top 15. However the team is intrigued with him,
and there is always the option of trading up.
Other top tier players of possible
interest
-Kentwan Balmer DE, North Carolina
-Limas Sweed WR, Texas
-Malcolm Kelly WR, Oklahoma
-Aqib Talib CB, Kansas
I’d love to see the team wisely spend
their top 2 picks on Dline-WR (or flip-flopped), possibly a Merling/Nelson
combo? However most of Redskins nation will be holding their breath
from now to draft day dreading the news that Dan Snyder has traded
this years draft and half of next years for Ocho Cinco, or whatever
strokes his urge to restore his teams place in the off-season
headlines.