Image
image
image
image


New York Giants Column

 

By: Kelly Grubb

7/8/09

2009 Training Camp Preview

 

Big Blue enters training camp as a team that has all of the talent to win the NFC East and go deep into the playoffs.  Like any season, the Giants need a few players to step up in key positions and need to remain healthy to be a real factor in this upcoming season.  Training camp will show which player will step up at the wide receiver position and which rookie will be ready to make a big impact during the upcoming season.  In this preview, I will highlight each position, focusing on starters and depth, highlight the top 5 training camp battles, and predicting the final 53 man roster at the end of camp. 

 

Position Analysis

 

Quarterback

 

Going into training camp the top two positions on the QB depth chart are set.  Eli Manning will likely head into training camp as one of the highest paid QBs in the league armed with the long term deal that will keep him a Giant for nearly the rest of his career.  He is still improving and should become a top 10 QB in the league for the next several years.  David Carr signed another 1 year deal with the G-men and will remain Manning’s key backup for this year until testing the free agent market to see which team will take a chance on reviving his career as a starting QB next off season.  The real competition at quarterback comes at the 3rd spot between former 6th round pick Andre Woodson and this year’s 5th round pick Rhett Bomar.  They are not only competing for a roster spot and likely red shirt year, but also the opportunity to serve as Manning’s backup for the next several years. 

 

Running Back

 

Armed with a new 4 year deal, that will keep him a Giant through his prime years, Brandon Jacobs returns as the force that keeps the Giants running game moving.  Jacobs will continue to be a 20-24 carry per game guy as long as he is healthy and effective.  The team will continue to go with whatever running back is most effective in their arsenal.  The question is who will fill the role that Derrick Ward has vacated when free agency arrived.  Third year back Ahmad Bradshaw is the front runner for the position of change of pace back and occasional starter to Jacobs.  Bradshaw is a more powerful runner than he looks and can be very effective in the Giants’ offense.  He is a decent pass catcher, but needs to work on his pass blocking and overall consistency.  Competing with Bradshaw will be second year player Danny Ware and rookie Andre Brown.  Both Ware and Brown have a similar build and are power runners.  They must show who has better pass catching and big play ability to get carries in this offense.  Fullback Madison Hedgecock returns as the hammer that opens up holes and blocks for whatever running backs is toting the rock. 

 

Wide Receiver

 

Losing both starting receivers in the offseason has left this position open and less experienced, but the Giants still have many viable options in the passing game.  Steve Smith returns as the most productive receiver.  He will be making the transition from slot receiver to one of the starting spots.  I believe he will likely move back to the slot position when the team goes into a 3 receiver set.  Domenik Hixon got plenty of time as a starter last season with all of Plaxico Burress’s legal issues.  Hixon has enough speed to be the deep receiver and cause defenses headaches when they try to crowd the line of scrimmage.  Likely, Smith and Hixon will be the starters, with Sinorice Moss and Mario Manningham competing for the 3rd wide receiver spot.  Both Moss and Manningham are smallish speed receiver that look to stretch the field deep.  Moss has struggled to stay healthy and be consistent during his 3 seasons with Big Blue.  He has had a great offseason and really needs to make a huge impact in the preseason and training camp.  Manningham had a disappointing rookie year and the team expects a much bigger impact from him in his second year. 

 

The team brought in some good talent via the draft in first rounder Hakeem Nicks and third rounder Ramses Barden.  Nicks has the reputation of being an extremely polished wide receiver and has shown that so far in minicamps and organized team activities.  He needs to consistently get open, make plays, and show he can block, if he wants to win one of the starting spots.  Barden is a huge athletic receiver making the jump from a FCS school.  He will likely fill the role of jump ball receiver inside the red zone for Big Blue.  The team also has special teams ace and Super Bowl 42 hero David Tyree on the roster competing for a spot. 

 

Tight End

 

Kevin Boss returns for a second season after showing he was able to be the fulltime starter to replace Jeremy Shockey.  Boss is a decent route runner and improving blocker that has enough moves to gain yards after a short catch.  He has not reached his full potential and will to continue to become a better player.  The Giants would still like more of a long distant threat over the middle to threaten the defense on the edge and out of the backfield.  This is the reason that the Giants drafted H-Back/TE Travis Beckum out of Wisconsin.  Beckum twice finished a season with over 900 yards receiving in a 12 games schedule.  The Giants envision lining him up in a two tight end set or in the backfield to threaten the defense with his speed.  The team will not ask him to offer much in terms of blocking.  Competing for the blocking tight end position will be Michael Matthews and Darcy Johnson.

 

Offensive Line

 

The same offensive line that allowed the Giants to lead the league in rushing last season and finish 4th in rushing in 2007 returns again completely intact.  The only concerns that the team has regarding the offensive line is aging and the potential of injuries slowing the teams’ progress.  This is why the team has stock piled backups and future prospects just in case any part of the line breaks down.  Returning at the tackles spots are right tackle Kareem McKenzie and left tackle David Diehl.  McKenzie is a powerful blocker in the running game and decent as an edge pass blocker.  He has struggled a little with back injuries and the team fears he is on the down side of his career.  Diehl has been solid on the edge since moving from his duty at guard and right tackle.  He seldom has a poor game and is never injured.  If a left tackle prospect works out, then I could see the team moving him to the right side again.  Backing up the starting tackles are Kevin Boothe, who has performed well when called upon to play at either tackle or guard.  Guy Whimper was drafted to be the left tackle of the future and has played well when called upon.  He simply has had too many injuries and has not developed fast enough.  The team drafted William Beatty out of UConn to be the new left tackle of the future.  Like Whimper, Beatty is a very agile athlete with even better feet.  Beatty has excellent potential and will likely pushed Whimper off the roster.

 

Big Blue has one of the best interior lines in the league with Pro Bowler Chris Snee and rugged Rich Seubert starting at the guard positions and Pro Bowler Shaun O’Hara at center.  Snee is excellent when leading the play via pulling and is a stout pass protector.  Seubert miraculously returned from a very bad leg injury to again become an effective starter.  O’Hara is an excellent leader and has solidified the line since coming to the Giants from Cleveland.  He is tough enough to take on the biggest defensive tackles and agile enough to pull and lead a play downfield.  Backing up the guard and center spots are Adam Koets and free agent signing Tutan Reyes, as well as Boothe.  Koets was drafted as a smaller tackle, but he is stout yet agile enough to play guard and the team has been working him in at center.  The G-men signed Reyes, whom has started 37 games at the guard and tackle positions.  Reyes is also experienced at center and will likely be competing with Koets for the last linemen spot. 

 

Defensive Line

 

With the healthy return of defensive end Osi Umenyiora to the Giants lineup, the team will again have the best pass rush in the NFL.  Umenyiora has 41 sacks in five years of play and has shown that he is among the best in the league at pressuring the passer.  He will again bring his sheer speed off of the snap and better than average run stopping skills back to the starting lineup.  While Umenyiora was injured last season, the Giants replaced one Pro Bowl defensive end with a new one.  Justin Tuck has 22 sacks in the last 2 seasons and he is still improving.  Tuck is one of the stronger pass rushers in the league and is excellent at stopping the run.  He is so strong he often rushes the passer from the defensive tackle position.  With Umenyiora out, Mathias Kiwanuka went again from strongside linebacker to defensive end in training camp and came through with a decent 8 sack campaign.  The team decided that the best way for Kiwanuka to reach his full potential is too allow him to stay at one spot.  He will stay at defensive end and use his pass rushing quickness to work as the 3rd pass rusher on obvious passing downs. 

 

Third year man Dave Tollefson, last year’s 6th round pick Robert Henderson, and rookie free agent Maurice Evans will compete for the last defensive end roster spot.  Tollefson is a solid player, but he saw a lot of time last season and got 3.5 sacks for Big Blue.  He needs to show that he can consistently pressure the passer.  Henderson has the most to prove since injuries ruined his rookie campaign.  Evans was an All American during his sophomore year at Penn State, but stupid decisions ruined his college career.  He has great pass rush potential and should give Tollefson a real run for his money in training camp. 

 

Starting defensive tackles Fred Robbins and Barry Cofield are both in the last years of their contracts and both had off season knee surgery, so the team stocked up on defensive tackles in the offseason.  Robbins is a very effective pass rusher and gets a great push up the middle on run downs.  He is 32 years old and showing signs that his body is breaking down.  Cofield is a blue collar plugger that is a solid starter and makes the occasional big play.  The team signed Chris Canty from the Cowboys, where he played defensive end in 3-4 defense.  Now he will play tackle in the 4-3 defense where he can use his strength, huge body, and quickness to his advantage.  The team also signed Rocky Bernard from Seattle to be a backup tackle and starter if required.  Bernard does not have great size, but his quickness will make him effective in spot duty.  Jay Alford returns as an interior pass rusher on obvious passing downs and the field goal snapper.

 

Linebacker

 

Antonio Pierce returns as middle linebacker and leader of this defense.  Pierce is 30, but remain a solid run defender and fast enough to be the short to intermediate zone defender on passing downs.  He has been a full time starter for 5 years and finished with over 95 tackles in each.  Backing up Pierce is Jonathon Goff and Chase Blackburn.  Goff spent most of his rookie season injured and did not make much of a contribution.  This training camp and preseason should give the team a real gauge of what he can do.  Blackburn keeps beating the odds to make the team and also start when called upon.  He is a hard worker, hustler, and solid player on defense and special teams.

 

The team signed Michael Boley to be the starter on the weakside and have Danny Clark returning as the starter on the strongside.  Clark is a good run defender, but is not athletic enough to be on the field on passing downs.  Boley is a solid player and probably the most athletic linebacker on the team, but he just had a hip surgery that will keep him out until right before the regular season.  With Boley out, second year player Bryan Kehl, Gerris Wilkinson, and Blackburn will be competing for the starting spot.  Kehl is an athletic player that showed he could be a good player when given the chance.  He collected 35 tackles in reserve duty and a starter for 2 games.  Wilkinson is a good athlete and a decent cover linebacker that is still improving as a run defender.  He has been injured a lot in the last couple of seasons and has not been getting better since his rookie seasons. 

 

Big Blue drafted Clint Sintim out of UVA to be the strongside backer of the future.  Sintim played as an outside pass rushing linebacker in a 3-4 defense at Virginia, but the Giants feel he has the ability to be a 4-3 linebacker.  He compiled 20 sacks in his junior and senior season combined and Big Blue would love to have another skilled rusher off the edge.  He will compete to take time away from Blackburn and starter Clark.  The Giants still have Zak DeOssie who serves as the team’s long snapper.  He has shown little as a linebacker.  He needs to show more as a special teams player and emergency linebacker. 

 

Cornerback

 

Big Blue has finally found a solid cornerback tandem in Aaron Ross and Corey Webster.  Both finished last season with 3 INTs a piece and were overall solid.  Both have the speed to stay with top receivers and the recognition ability on routes to make plays.  The best part about this duo is that they are 26 and 27, respectively, and are each signed through the next 3 seasons.  Second year player Terrell Thomas returns to compete with veteran Kevin Dockery for the nickel cornerback position.  Dockery is a solid cover corner despite only being 5’8”.  Thomas played well for a rookie and has better size, but he does not have Dockery’s experience.  The team would love to have Thomas prove in training camp and the preseason that he can be the 3rd cornerback.  Dockery was resigned to only a 1 year deal and will likely be gone after this season. 

 

With the loss of both veteran corners Sam Madison and R.W. McQuarters, the team needs another player to step up as depth in case of injury.  This is why the team drafted two corners in the late rounds of this years’ draft.  Sixth round pick DeAndre Wright out of New Mexico and seventh rounder Stoney Woodson out of South Carolina will try to prove that they have what it takes to be pros.  Both will need to prove that they can stay with NFL receivers, help defend against the running game, and most importantly, contribute on special teams.  They have very similar size, good speed, and Wright has more experience and possibly skill.

 

Safety

 

With the loss of the secondary’s veteran leader James Butler, the team will be relying on youth in the deep middle.  Last season, top rookie Kenny Philips will hold down the free safety job because he is an excellent athlete.  Philips started 3 games and played in all 16 games as a rookie finishing with 67 tackles and 1 INT.  The team is happy with his work as a run defender, but it would love to see him be more of a playmaker.  Michael Johnson will be the guy at the strong safety position because of his size and hitting ability.  He will be competing against free agent pickup C.C. Brown from the Texans.  Brown is a savvy veteran with lots of starting experience whom is better against the run than the pass.  He must show that he can make plays on the ball to beat out Johnson for a starting safety spot.  If the Giants decide to keep 4 safeties, then it will likely be a rookie free agent with Sha’reff Rashad and Steve Cargile competing for the spot. 

 

Special Teams

 

The Giants are set at the snapper spots with Zak DeOssie manning the long snapping duties and Jay Alford as the field goal snapper.  The team allowed veteran and surprise Pro Bowl kicker John Carney to walk meaning that Lawrence Tynes will be handed the kicking job again.  He is solid, although he does miss an occasional kick, unlike the veteran Carney.  He is much better at kickoffs then Carney.  Returning for a 22nd year is the best directional and one of the best punters in NFL history Jeff Feagles.  If the NFL Hall of Fame selection committee ever realizes that punters do play a key role in football, then Feagles might be the first or second inducted at his position. 

 

Kickoff and punt returning could be a problem because the team’s best returners play key offensive role that might disqualify them from being returners.  With Domenik Hixon and Ahmad Bradshaw likely playing major roles on offense the team will look elsewhere.  Unless they keep Bradshaw or Hixon because they are too good to pass up, I think it is Mario Manningham, Sinorice Moss, or maybe Danny Ware or Andre Brown competing for the kick and punt return roles. 

 

Top Training Camp Battles

 

5. Swing Tackle

            Guy Whimper vs. William Beatty

Whimper was originally drafted by the Giants because of his athletic ability and his feet.  He has shown in his 3 seasons that he does have adequate ability, but injuries have set him back.  He saw a lot of playing time in the Giants 2007 playoff win against the Buccaneers and performed very well.  He spent last season on injured reserve with a broken foot.  He must show that that injury did not hurt he pass blocking ability.  He will be competing against this season’s 2nd round pick out of Connecticut.  Beatty has very good feet, agility, and more experience as a tackle playing his entire college career rather than 1 year, like Whimper.  Beatty has the size, agility, and upside to peak the Giants interest if he plays well in camp and the preseason.  My prediction is that Beatty shows enough to make Whimper expendable.  Beatty will be the third tackle for this season and left tackle of the future. 

 

4. Blocking Tight End

            Michael Matthews vs. Darcy Johnson

Matthews has filled this role for the last two season admirably with perfect size (6’4”, 270 lbs.) and strength.  Matthews has a lot of experience working out of the two tight end set and blocking out of the backfield.  He is even sometimes used at the fullback spot to lead run plays or be the extra blocker in pass protection.  Johnson also has decent size (6’5”, 267lbs.) and is a little better in the passing game.  His issue is that he has had injury problems and the team does not need another pass catching tight end with the drafting of H-back Travis Beckum.  Matthews will win this job with his run and pass blocking ability.

 

3. Weakside Linebacker (Temporary Starter)

            Bryan Kehl vs. Gerris Wilkinson vs. Chase Blackburn

This is a training camp battle only because of the recent surgery to starter Michael Boley.  The team did not sign Boley to a five year $25 million deal for him to be a backup, so this spot is only until Boley is healthy.  Each of these three has experience starting at this spot in the last season.  Blackburn started eight games at the weakside linebacker position gathering 43 tackles.  Blackburn is a solid football player, but not the athlete that is required for the position.  Kehl started two games and collected 31 tackles as a starter and in spot duty.  Kehl is better suited for the position than Blackburn because of his speed, agility, and pass coverage skills.  He needs to show more consistency in his second full year.  Wilkinson is a solid athlete but injuries and ineffectiveness have hampered his playing time with the G-men.  He is solid against the pass but in 5 games as a starter last season he collected only 10 tackles.  This is his last chance to prove he can be a player for this team.  I believe Kehl will get another chance to show what he can do with Blackburn waiting in the wings and playing the role of first linebacker off the bench.  Wilkinson unfortunately will not make it too the regular season with the Giants.

 

2. Strong Safety

            Michael Johnson vs. C.C. Brown

Both players have very similar attributes.  They are both very good run defender that like to hit, but they need to show more against the pass.  Whoever shows the ability to play a short zone and play the ball will get this starting spot.  Johnson has slightly better size (6’2” to Brown’s 6’0”) and he is better trusted because of his experience with the team.  Brown will have to outplay Johnson in the preseason and camp to get the spot.  I think each player is similar and will hold their own in camp and the preseason, so that means the trusted 3 year veteran of the Giants Johnson gets the job and Brown will be the top reserve.

 

1.      Wide Receiver

Steve Smith vs. Domenik Hixon vs. Hakeem Nicks vs. Sinorice Moss vs. Mario Mannigham vs. David Tyree vs. Ramses Barden

Each player has their strengths and weaknesses.  Smith and Nicks have great hands, run very good routes, and catch almost anything thrown at them.  Nicks has shown this in minicamp and will continue to show it in training camp and the preseason.  Neither though will catch the 40 yard bomb on a regular basis.  Moss and Manningham have deep speed and can stretch the field but neither can hold up over the middle.  Each weighs in the 185 lb. range and has to show some sort of consistency over the course of a season. Hixon and Tyree have similar skills including the ability to get open in the medium range and occasionally get open for the deep ball.  They both can make spectacular plays, but fail to make the easy play.  Hixon is the more consistent receiver and has more ability than Tyree.  Hixon is an improving receiver that could surprise in camp and the preseason.  Time will be the only thing to sort out this logjam but here is my best guess.  I think Smith is the most solid bet for a starter spot because he is tough, seldom injured, and always gets open.  Manning has a great report with him and that will help.  I think Nicks shows enough in camp and the preseason to steal the other starting spot in camp or early in the regular season.  If Nicks is not quite ready Hixon will be the other starter or at the very least the third receiver.  He would play on the outside with Smith moving to the slot spot.  Manningham vs. Moss is the toughest to tell because I believe one will miss considerable time from injury and that could throw a curve in this whole prediction.  Assuming both are healthy, Moss gets the 4th receiver spot with Barden serving as the red zone specialist and Mannigham getting the last receiver spot because he will show enough as a returner to make the team.  David Tyree is solid but he is 29 and does not offer enough upside to be a long term contributor.  I would love if the team kept this Super Bowl hero, but I would have also loved if the team kept the Giants G.O.A.T. receiver Amana Toomer.  Unfortunately, this is not fantasy, reality can be a cold place with a 53 man roster limit.

 

Final Regular Season Roster

 

            Player                                 Number    Height             Weight             College

 

QB#1  Eli Manning                            10        6’4”                 225lbs.             Mississippi

QB#2  David Carr                              8          6’3”                 216lbs.             Fresno State

QB#3  Rhett Bomar                           5          6’2”                 225lbs.             Sam Houston St.

 

Comment:  Bomar beats out Woodson because of his decision making ability, confidence, and quick release.  He has the upside and swagger that Woodson simply does not have.

 

RB#1   Brandon Jacobs                       27        6’4”                 265lbs.             Southern Illinois

RB#2   Ahmad Bradshaw                   44        5’9”                 198lbs.             Marshall

RB#3   Danny Ware                            28        6’0”                 234lbs.             Georgia

RB#4   Andre Brown                          22        6’0”                 224lbs.             N.C. State

 

FB#1   Madison Hedgecock               39        6’3”                 266lbs.             North Carolina

 

 

Comment:  The best ground attack in the game returns with a deeper arsenal.

 

WR#1  Steve Smith                             12        5’11”               195lbs.             Southern California

WR#2  Domenik Hixon                      87        6’2”                 182lbs.             Akron

WR#3  Hakeem Nicks                         18        6’1”                 215lbs.             North Carolina

WR#4  Sinorice Moss                          83        5’8”                 185lbs.             Miami (FL)

WR#5  Ramses Barden                       13        6’6”                 227lbs.             Cal Poly

WR#6  Mario Mannigham                   82        5’11”               183lbs.             Michigan

 

Comment:  A young, but very talented corp. of receivers that I think will surprise.

 

TE#1   Kevin Boss                              89        6’6”                 253lbs.             Western Oregon

TE#2   Michael Matthews                  88        6’4”                 270lbs.             Georgia Tech

TE#3   Travis Beckum                        47        6’3”                 239lbs.             Wisconsin

 

Comment:  As long as Beckum remains healthy, this is an overall stronger groups than last season because they are more of a pass catching threat. 

 

LT       David Diehl                            66        6’5”                 319lbs.             Illinois

LG       Rich Seubert                           69        6’3”                 310lbs.             Western Illinois

C         Shaun O’Hara                         60        6’3”                 303lbs.             Rutgers

RG      Chris Snee                               76        6’3”                 317lbs.             Boston College

RT       Kareem McKenzie                  67        6’6”                 327lbs.             Penn State

T          William Beatty                        65        6’6”                 307lbs.             Connecticut

T/G      Kevin Boothe                          77        6’5”                 315lbs.             Cornell

C/T      Adam Koets                            61        6’5”                 300lbs.             Oregon State

 

Comment:  A deep and talented unit that should see no drop off from the last two seasons successes.

 

DE#1   Osi Umenyiora                        72        6’3”                 261lbs.             Troy State

DE#2   Justin Tuck                              91        6’5”                 274lbs.             Notre Dame

DE#3   Mathias Kiwanuka                  94        6’5”                 265lbs.             Boston College

DE#4   Maurice Evans                        74        6’2”                 264lbs.             Penn State

 

DT#1   Chris Canty                             99        6’7”                 304lbs.             Virginia

DT#2   Fred Robbins                          98        6’4”                 317lbs.             Wake Forest

DT#3   Barry Cofield                          96        6’4”                 306lbs.             Northwestern

DT#4   Rocky Bernard                        95        6’3”                 308lbs.             Texas A&M

DT#5   Jay Alford                               73        6’3”                 304lbs.             Penn State

 

Comment:  The area the needed to contribute more at the end of last season goes into this season restocked and improved.

 

MLB#1  Antonio Pierce                     58        6’1”                 238lbs.             Arizona

MLB#2  Jonathon Goff                      54        6’2”                 236lbs.             Vanderbilt

 

SLB#1  Danny Clark                          55        6’2”                 245lbs.             Illinois

SLB#2  Clint Sintim                           97        6’2”                 256lbs.             Virginia

SLB#3  Zak DeOssie                          51        6’4”                 249lbs.             Brown

 

WLB#1  Michael Boley                      52        6’3”                 223lbs.             Southern Mississippi

WLB#2  Bryan Kehl                           53        6’2”                 237lbs.             BYU

WLB#3  Chase Blackburn                  57        6’3”                 247lbs.             Akron

 

Comment:  Another improved area that should help the team reach greater success.

 

CB#1   Aaron Ross                             31        6’0”                 197lbs.             Texas

CB#2   Corey Webster                        23        6’0”                 202lbs.             Louisiana State

CB#3   Terrell Thomas                        24        6’0”                 199lbs.             Southern California

CB#4   Kevin Dockery                        39        5’8”                 188lbs.             Mississippi State

CB#5   DeAndre Wright                     26        5’10”               198lbs.             New Mexico

CB#6   Stoney Woodson                    29        5’10”               198lbs.             South Carolina

 

Comment:  A young, but very talented group that should return as strong as last season.

 

S#1      Kenny Phillips                         21        6’2”                 210lbs.             Miami (FL)

S#2      Michael Johnson                     20        6’2”                 207lbs.             Arizona

S#3      C.C. Brown                             41        6’0”                 208lbs.             Louisiana-Lafeyette

 

Comment:  This position was the biggest question because I think Sha’reff Rashad might steal a roster spot from either CB Woodson or Wright.

 

K         Lawrence Tynes                      1          6’1”                 202lbs.             Troy State

P          Jeff Feagles                             19        6’1”                 215lbs.             Miami (FL)

 

Comment:  The one unit that I am not convinced has improved for the long haul since last season.  Yes, that comment is directed at you Tynes.

 

Overall, the Giants have the potential of winning the NFC East and going deep into the playoffs, but first they must survive training camp, the preseason, and the regular season.

 

5/14/09

2009 NEW YORK GIANTS DRAFT REVIEW

Big Blue went into the 2009 draft with a couple major needs and came away with the players that may be capable of fillings these needs now and others for the long term.  The major need the team had for replacements for last years starters Plaxico Burress and Amani Toomer. The other basic needs for the Gmen included a strongside linebacker, safety, a backup offensive lineman, a cornerback, and a backup quarterback.  When you consider that the team selected value players at each of these positions with the exception of safety.  The proposed trade for Braylon Edwards or Anquan Boldin did not go through because each team was asking for too much.  The Giants responded by drafting 2 wide receivers in the top 3 rounds and a pass catching tight end. While these players may not have the immediate impact that the fan base would hope for, this draft will be a good one in the future.  As any good NFL football analyst would say, free agency is for immediate needs and the draft is for future consideration.  Not only did Big Blue stock the shelves for the future, the name of the game for the Giants in this draft was value picks.

 First Round: 29th pick (29th overall)

Hakeem Nicks- WR 6’1” 212lbs. North Carolina

The problem with having this need at wide receiver going into the draft is that receivers typically take the longest time to develop into NFL players.  While the Giants have decent wide receivers on the roster that they can win with, they need more playmakers.  Hakeem Nicks is one of the most polished an NFL ready receiver in the draft. Nicks was a very productive receiver at UNC that played really well in big games, especially his over 200 yard receiving performance against West Virginia in this year’s Meineke Car Care Bowl.

Nicks is fast enough and has the strength to break a jam at the line of scrimmage to get open.  He has excellent hands, as where evident in his now famous behind the back circus catch in the bowl game.  He is a very good athlete with enough quickness that is tough after the catch and will fight to gain the extra yards.  What remains to be seen is how Nicks holds up speed wise against NFL cornerbacks and how effective he is at blocking.  If he wants to be a starter in the NFL, especially for the Giants, he needs to block downfield.

Nicks will likely fit on the Giants as a number 1 (x  receiver) or a #2 (z receiver).  That will depend on how well he performs in training camp and in the preseason.  If Nicks can show that he can run proper routes, get open, and make consistent plays.  I think Nicks will fit with the top 3 of the Giants WRs with Domenik Hixon and Steve Smith. The team may even go the way of the committee route and start the top 2 performers  in the camp/ the preseason and have the third play the slot position.

 Second Round: 13th pick (45th overall)

Clint Sintim- OLB 6’3” 256lbs. Virginia

As predicted the team looked to shore up the strongside linebacker position in the draft.  Some teams and draft rating services has Sintim listed as being a potential late 1st round early 2nd round pick, so he is a great value where the team selected him.  Sintim is a very big defender that came from a 3-4 defensive system at UVA. Despite being a 3-4 pass rushing backer in college, the Giants are convinced that he can make the transition to a strongside backer in a 4-3 system.  The key reason that they selected him is because he is a great value and an excellent college pass rusher off the edge.

Sintim packs a lot of size and strength into his chiseled body that is capable of delivering hard hits anywhere on the field.  He plays the game with an attitude and aggressiveness that the team really likes and fits on the Big Blue defense.  From watching some film, this backer does a good job fighting through blockers to make a tackle and he has a closing burst of speed that most good one do.  Sintim might be a little stiff in his hips and he is certainly not a proven pass coverage backer but the team is not looking for him to play going backwards, he is going to be used as another pass rusher.

Clint Sintim will be competing in training camp for the strongside linebacker position with    veteran Danny Clark.  Sintim biggest plus is the fact that he collected 26 sacks in college and the fact that Clark is more of a 1st and 2nd down run defender.  Clark will likely play on the run down with Sintim seeing snaps on 3rd and longs and other passing downs.  The team could have the makings of an even better pass rush package if new coordinator Bill Sheridan utilizes all of his players correctly.  I imagine any team would struggle to face a pass rush of Osi Umenyiora and Mathias Kiwanuka at DE, Justin Tuck
rushing from the inside next to our best pass rushing DT, maybe newly acquired Chris Canty, and Sintim rushing off the end as a stand up pass rushing linebacker.  Back that up with newly acquired Michael Boley as the athletic pass covering linebacker and a nickel package of DBs.  Most teams in the NFL would have alot of trouble passing the ball against that front and even fewer offensive lines will be able to block it consistently.


Second Round: 28th pick (60th overall)

William Beatty- OT 6’6” 307lbs. Connecticut

Here is another case where a player that some NFL teams and draft rating services had rated as a late 1st round early 2nd round pick fell to be a great value selection for the Gmen.  Beatty is a very athletic tackle that plays with quickness because he is very light on his feet.  He is able to pull off the line of scrimmage and attack defenders at the 2nd level of the defense.  On film, what impresses is how he locks up defenders and keeps fighting to the whistle.   In the International Bowl against Buffalo, Beatty makes a great play that highlights his skills set where he gets of the snap quickly to place his head up defender inside then then spins to the outside and pulls to be the lead blocker ahead of a designed QB bootleg that ends as a 17 yard TD run with Beatty making the key block at the end zone.  Some question his strength or if he is polished enough as a blocker to contribute right away, but he benched 225lbs 27 times which put him in the top end of the class and regarding the polish comment, the team does not need Beatty to contribute right away barring injury.

The Giants offensive line is set for the upcoming seasons at each position of the offensive line.  Both of the Giants tackles are
reaching their 30s and Kareem McKenzie has recently had minor back issues.  The team has Guy Whimper and Adam Koets as backup tackles but I do not think the team is set on either being a long term solution in case of injury.  Beatty will be competing with Whimper and Koets for the swing tackle position.  The swing tackle is the backup on either side.  While Beatty is probably better suited to play the left tackle position, the need will likely need a right tackle first.  If McKenzie were to break done, I imagine that Diehl would slide back over to right tackle and Beatty would be the left tackle because of his feet.

Third Round: 21st pick (85th overall)

Ramses Barden- WR 6’6” 229lbs. Cal Poly

In their second attempt to fill the shoes of Burress and Toomer, the Giants selected the only receiver in this draft to match the size of Burress, Ramses Barden of FCS Division (IAA) Cal Poly.  This extremely lengthy receiver has a similar skill set to Burress who used that to dominate at a lower level of college competition.  He has great hands, is a very good blocker, and does a decent job adjusting to the ball in the air and winning jump balls.  Barden finished his college career as the leading receiver in the school’s history and the record setter for most TD receptions at the Division IAA level with 50 TDs and the most consecutive games with TD catches.  Questions remain about his speed, route running, and whether Barden can be successful playing against NFL competition.  He played very well against Wisconsin and San Diego State, keeping his team in the game winning against San Diego State and taking Wisconsin to overtime.  Barden had 6 catches for 83 yards and a TD against the Badgers and 7 catches for 161 yards and a TD against the Aztecs.  If these games are any indicator then Barden
should be able to do just fine at the NFL level.

Barden fits on the Giants as the new red zone jump ball threat. Barden has the one thing that no other receiver on the roster has, size.  Each Giants receiver, with a shot to make the roster,  is less than 6‘1”.  In college, his bread and butter play was the fade route in the end zone and that will not change in the pros.  He will likely get early snaps inside the 20 yard line and will be used matched up on the outside against a smaller defensive back.  If Barden shows that he can be the effective blocker that Burress and Toomer were then he will earn even more snaps in the offense.

 Third Round: 36th pick (100th overall)

Travis Beckum- TE 6’3” 243lbs. Wisconsin

Beckum was a stud receiving tight end his sophomore and junior seasons before missing much of his senior year with a broken fibula.  He is a speedy receiver with good route running skills and downfield speed to beat linebackers.  He has good hands and can dodge tacklers to gain yards after the catch.  Beckum has the strength to break jams at the line of scrimmage and the wiggle to make tacklers miss and gain those important yards after contact.  The biggest knock on Beckum is that he
is weak as a blocker and has a history of injuries.  He might be able to overcome his blocking deficiencies with work.  He has the strength as previously mentioned and as evidence by his leading the tight ends at the NFL combine with 28 reps on the 225lb. bench press.  As for his injuries, only time will tell, but he is definitely worth the risk because of his production and ability when healthy.

Beckum will compete for the backup tight end position behind starter Kevin Boss with Michael Matthews and Darcy Johnson.  Beckum will definitely make the roster because he will have a role that is completely separate from Boss.  He will lineup at the H-back position and may even be on the field with Boss.  The H back is a hybrid fullback and tight end that will often line up in the backfield at the fullback spot on passing downs.  The last real H back that the Giants utilized was Pete Mitchell and Beckum is a better receiving threat and athlete than Mitchell.  Beckum will add another dimension and threat to a near potent offense.  The media will look at the release of Burress and say that there is no one on the roster that can replace his production.  While that is true, the team will utilize the combined threat of Beckum, Barden, and Nicks to replace all of the facets of Burress’s game.

 Fourth Round: 29th pick (129th overall)

Andre Brown- RB 6’0” 224lbs. NC State

Brown had a productive college career, but not as productive as it likely should have been because of various injuries and splitting carries in the Wolf pack backfield.   He finished his college career with 523 carries rushing for 2,539 yards and 22 TDs.  Brown has a strength, enough speed, and the wiggle to make a defender miss in the open field.  The Giants like his receiving ability and versatility. Brown had a good average per carry (over 4 yards throughout his career) and could serve as a short yardage and third down back.  His work ethic and versatility will be valuable to Big Blue.

Brown will compete with Ahmad Bradshaw and Danny Ware for carries in the backup role.  The Giants rotation of running backs is extremely important because of the pounding that Brandon Jacobs takes with his running style.  The team selected Brown because he compares favorably to former Giants RB Derrick Ward.  He can be a receiver, change of pace, pounder, or whatever else is necessary.  If Brown can prove that he is a decent blocker on blitz pickups then he might be able to take time away from Bradshaw, but he will likely compete head to head with Ware for the third RB role.

 Fifth Round: 15th pick (151st overall)

Rhett Bomar- QB 6’2” 225lbs. Sam Houston State

Bomar began his college career at the University of Oklahoma as a top high school prospect.  He started 12 games at Oklahoma as a redshirt freshman and led the team to  a bowl winning season.  He was forced to transfer to a FCS team because of an NCAA violation, where Bomar excepted money for work that he did not do.  While finishing his career at Sam Houston State, Bomar passed as a senior for 3,355 yards with a 56.2 completion percentage with 27 touchdowns and 13 INTs. Bomar produced 7,582 yards with a 56.4 completion percentage along with 47 TDs and 29 INTs.

Bomar has a strong arm with solid throwing mechanics and a quick release.  He has a solid build, shorter than optimum, and is athletic enough to avoid the rush and still be accurate.  Bomar has a quick release and good vision for finding receivers downfield for the deep ball.  Many scouts question his intangibles and some take him as cocky instead of an aggressive leader.  Few will question his measurables and the upside that he showed throughout his big and small school
college career.

Bomar will compete in training camp with last season’s 6th round pick Andre Woodson.  Woodson did little to impress in last year’s training camp and preseason.  Woodson spent the year on the practice squad.  In terms of mechanic, Bomar has the edge, but the team will give the edge to whomever performs better in the preseason.  This is a major training camp battle because backup David Carr will be gone after this season.  The winner of this job will be Eli Manning’s backup in the future.

 Sixth Round: 27th pick (200th overall)

DeAndre Wright- CB 5’11” 198lbs. New Mexico

Wright’s durability concerns caused him to fall in this draft.  He had post season shoulder surgeries and has a slight build.  He has the speed, hands, and is a willing run defender despite his size.  Wright played frequently through injuries demonstrating his toughness.  He is not a finished product and has a battle to win a roster spot.   Wright will compete for the last cornerback spot on the roster.  The team is set with Corey Webster and Aaron Ross as starters and Terrell Thomas
and Kevin Dockery as nickel and dime.  Wright has to show that he has special teams ability to make the final roster as well as his ability to make plays on the ball.


 Seventh Round: 29th pick (238th overall)

Stoney Woodson- CB 5’11” 197lbs. South Carolina

Woodson has decent size, speed, and competed against SEC receivers throughout his career.  Spent most of his career as a backup and made 5 INTs as a starter during his senior year.   Woodson has shown he is willing in run support and could possibly play safety in the pros because of his college experience.   Woodson is not a great athlete and must show that he has the speed to be an NFL player.  Not only will Woodson compete for the 5th cornerback spot but he could also compete for the Giants 4th safety spot behind starters Kenny Phillips and Michael Johnson and backup C.C. Brown.  Versatility and showing that he is a capable special teams player is the ticket to a regular season roster spot for Woodson.

Overall

The Giants had a good overall draft filling their few critical needs, finding players that could contribute this season and in the future, and even landed a potential undrafted free agent steal in Penn State DE Maurice Evans.  Evans got 12 sacks as a sophomore on a Big Ten powerhouse and a few mistakes, no worse than Bomars, landed him out of the draft.  Evans will be competing for the teams fourth DE position with Dave Tollefson.  With Evans and Sintim added to an already powerful pass rush, the team has the potential for a lights out pass rush that could be even better than in the Super Bowl.

 

3/31/09

2009 New York Giants Draft Preview

 

As the team heads into the 2009 NFL Draft on Saturday, April 25th, they have a short list of absolute needs with a long list of picks and options.  In this draft preview, I will approach the Giants draft from the scenario of best player available, as well as by need, and like the team does not trade or move any of its draft picks.  The team has 10 overall picks in the 7 round draft with 5 being on the first day and 3 within the top 60 picks.  As I mentioned, I will approach this like the team does not trade any picks however I really see the team packaging picks to move up to get a targeted player or two or packaging picks to trade for a player.  This draft for the Giants should be an opportunity to really target 3-4 top player to get and build the future with.

 

Team Needs

 

1.      Wide Receiver- With the situation of Plaxico Burress still up in the air and Amani Toomer’s stellar career as a Giant over, this is a top priority.  Even if Burress manages to keep himself from jail or suspension for his November 28, 2008 arrest for illegal possession of a firearm, the team still has getting a receiver as a top priority because Burress will be 32 for this season and is nearing the end of his days as a top QB target.  With Burress, the team has an excellent core of receivers, but without Burress excellence turns to pedestrian, as we saw for the last games of the 2008 season.  Domenik Hixon, Steve Smith, Mario Manningham, and Sinorice Moss can escape coverage, find holes, and be fairly effective; however no one of the group is a receiver that strikes fear into a defense, demand a double team matchup, or consistently wins jump balls in the end zone.  The team needs a tall target that commands the respect of the defense down the field and in the end zone.  They need someone that could serve as a #1 receiver for the future.  This draft has several options that will be available at the end of the first round at the #29 draft position.   Tall receivers like Kenny Britt of Rutgers, Hakeem Nicks of North Carolina, and Darrius Heyward-Bey of Maryland would all fit the Giants need.  The team must decide which has the brightest future and the best chance to help now, if possible.

 

2.      Linebacker- The team is set on the weakside with the signing of Michael Boley and likely set in the middle with veteran Antonio Pierce, but the strongside remains a potential weak spot with veteran Danny Clark returning to fill the role.  Not only should the team get a player to compete on the strongside, but the team must also begin thinking of an eventual successor for Pierce, who will be 30 this season.  The team will look for this type of player anywhere from the mid 1st and mid to late 2nd round of this draft.  I do think the team will trade up and target a specific player here.  Assuming the team stays put in the 2nd round at the #13 (45 overall), they should grab the best inside or outside linebacker on the board.  At this spot, one of the better linebackers in the draft will slide to the mid second round.  Players like Brian Cushing or Clay Matthews of USC or Cody Brown of Connecticut, or Darryl Beckwith of LSU will be available.  The team needs a player that will challenge Danny Clark for the starting spot and play the middle in the future. 

 

3.      Safety- Right now, the team would be okay with Kenny Phillips starting at one spot and Michael Johnson and free agent C.C. Brown competing for the other safety spot.  Big Blue is running dangerously thin at the safety spot and needs to pick up a backup for this season and potential starter for the future.  They will target a player with decent size, speed, tackling ability, and good hands.  Every team wants a safety that can stop the run and make some interceptions.  This draft is not great at the safety spot, but it has several players that will be available at the end of the 2nd or 3rd round that could be playmakers in this league.  I personally like the play of Patrick Chung of Oregon, or players like Darcel McBath of Texas Tech or Rashad Johnson of Alabama have the hands, ball skills, and ability to be a solid starter, immediate backup, and great special teams player.

 

4.      Offensive Tackle and Guard- The Big Blue offensive line is one of the best in the league and is signed through the next 3 seasons.  However, depth is always a great weapon to have and the team could always use more.  I am not sure the Giants are sold on Guy Whimper or Adam Koets as a top reserve and emergency starter for either tackle spot.  The team does like reserve tackle/guard Kevin Boothe, but fellow reserve Grey Ruegamer, who plays guard and center, is aging and an unrestricted free agent that will not be back.  A player that can serve as a backup center and a player that could be an emergency tackle should be mid round targets for the Giants.  Eric Wood of Louisville, Max Unger of Oregon, or Trevor Canfield of Cincinnati fit the bill as an interior reserve.  Phil Loadholt of Oklahoma, Troy Kropog of Tulane, and Gerald Cadogan of Penn State are all tackles that could compete with Guy Whimper or Adam Koets for the back tackle positions.

 

5.      Cornerback- The team needs a fifth corner despite having a great quartet in starters Aaron Ross, and Corey Webster with nickel and dime corners Terrell Thomas and Kevin Dockery.  This position gets consideration as a need because Dockery will likely be gone after next season and you always need 4 solid corners in the pass happy NFL of today.   Second day corners like Bruce Johnson of Miami, Sean Smith of Utah, or Mike Mickens of Cincinnati among others would make the roster as a special teamer and provide great depth at cornerback. 

 

6.      Quarterback- After another season of caddying for Eli Manning, David Carr will be ready to again try to prove he can be a starting quarterback in the NFL.  Carr provides an excellent backup for Manning and has proved that he can start when needed; however after Carr, the team has little at QB.  Big Blue tried to find a future backup with the selection of Andre Woodson last season.  Woodson showed little in the preseason going 3 for 9 with an interception.  The team still has Anthony Wright, but he is 33 years old and not a future answer.  The team could look for a QB anywhere from the 3rd to 6th rounds, depending on who is available and at what value.  Some of the 2nd day QBs that I believe could develop and that the team might want are Graham Harrell of Texas Tech, Drew Wiley of Buffalo, or Nate Davis out of Ball State.

 

Giants Mock Draft

 

First Round: 29th pick (29th overall)

 

Kenny Britt- WR 6’3” 218lbs. Rutgers

The team targets the top available big playmaker and Britt fits the bill.  He is a muscular wide receiver that gets open over the middle and makes plays.  Britt has impressive abilities after the catch and does a very nice job using his body to shield defenders on jump balls.  He worked throughout his Rutgers career to get better and better as a blocker and helped Ray Rice and R.U.’s other runners.  Britt was very productive at Rutgers despite having an inconsistent quarterback and not much of a running game last season.  He would immediately help the Giants as a red zone target and would help to draw down field coverage, opening things up for Big Blue’s smaller receivers that excel finding holes in the underneath zone coverage.  Even if Burress returns this season without a suspension, Britt would have a role as a 2nd or 4th receiver.  Burress could mentor Britt as to how to play the NFL game.  If Britt is not available then Hakeem Nicks out of North Carolina would be an excellent pickup as well.

 

Second Round: 13th pick (45th overall)

 

Clay Matthews- OLB 6’3” 246lbs. USC

Matthews is moving up draft boards but I am wagering that he may be available at this spot.  Matthews flies around the football field making hard hits while showing an excellent motor and range.  He has excellent ability to blitz the passer, something that the Giants would love him to do.  Matthews was buried behind first rounder Keith Rivers until his senior season at USC, but still received a fair amount of playing time.  While a reserve, Matthews got lots of experience playing special teams, standing out for his kick and punt coverage ability.  He has a football pedigree from his father, an All American linebacker, and his brothers, each a division I defender.  Matthews would compete this season with Danny Clark for playing time on the strong side.  Should Matthews not be available then Cody Brown of Connecticut would definitely be available. 

 

Second Round: 28th pick (60th overall)

 

Patrick Chung- S 5’11” 207lbs. Oregon

This is one of those player that as a fan, I would really want on my team.  Chung is a very aggressive run supporter and a decent open field tackler.  He was a 4 year starter at Oregon despite getting a late start on football (raised in Jamaica as a soccer player).  He has above average quickness, the ability to change directions, and adequate bulk.  He is a little shorter than the optimum NFL starter, but he makes up for that with excellent hands and ball skills.  Chung would compete immediately with Johnson and Brown for the strong safety spot opposite Kenny Philips.  He also would provide leadership and has great special teams ability.  If he was not available then Rashad Johnson of Alabama would be the next best option. 

 

Third Round: 27th pick (91st overall)

 

Eric Wood- C/G 6’4” 304lbs. Louisville

Wood is an experienced center that likes to maul his opponents and offers good quickness.  He brings a nasty attitude to go along with excellent strength to the interior of an offensive line.  This lineman has decent mobility and can pull and get to the second level of defenders.  This ability fits what the Giants regularly ask their interior linemen to do.  Despite being a little inconsistent technique wise and a little stiff, Wood has the ability to be an emergency starter at center or guard early in his career.  He would immediately fill the role that Grey Ruegamer filled for the last couple seasons for the G-men.

 

Third Round: 36th pick (100th overall)

 

Graham Harrell- QB 6’2” 223lbs. Texas Tech

While he is not NFL ready and is already being labeled a product of the pass happy Mike Leach system, Harrell has the most potential out of any of the uber-productive Texas Tech QBs of the last 10 years.  Harrell has decent arm strength, good vision down field, and lots of experience being a 3 year starter for the Red Raiders.  This QB has an excellent football IQ going through his progressions in the complicated spread attack of the Red Raiders.  You also cannot argue with his production throwing for over 10,000 yards and 93 touchdowns in the last two seasons combined with only 23 INTs.  He does not have a huge arm and will have to adjust to taking snaps under center, but I think he is a closer fit for what the Giants do than Andre Woodson, last year’s Big Blue QB draft pick.  I saw several Texas Tech games last season and what impressed me the most about him is his ability to find the open man and place the ball where it needed to be regardless of how big or little the throwing lane was at the time.  Harrell could serve as a clip board holding #3 QB, while learning the offense and how to be an NFL QB under two former #1 overall picks.  I think with a year of learning, he could be Eli Manning’s primary backup for the 2010 season.  If Harrell is gone, then I think the team waits a round or so to select a QB like Drew Wiley of Buffalo.

 

Fourth Round: 29th pick (129th overall)

 

Gerald Cadogan- OT 6’5” 309lbs. Penn State

Cadogan is a big athlete with the strength and long arms to be an effective tackle in the NFL.  He moves well and is light on his feet with the ability to pull outside ahead of a toss sweep and clear a lane.  Cadogan started for two seasons at left tackle and one at guard for the Nittany Lions.  He did a very nice job protecting QB Daryll Clark and opening lanes for RB Evan Royster.  For the Giants, he would compete for the role of swing tackle backing up either spot and serving as a goal line tight end.  Cadogan will need to fine tune his technique and get stronger to be a long term starter on the pro level.  If Cadogan is gone by this point, the team may take a shot at Troy Kropog of Tulane.

 

Fifth Round: 28th pick (164th overall)

 

Bruce Johnson- CB 5’10” 174lbs. Miami

Johnson has the speed and quickness to stay with NFL receivers and the ability to read pass while playing in zone coverage.  He is a willing run supporter despite his lack of overall size and strength.  He is a good athlete but he needs further time to develop as a football player and will have to work on turning and running with receivers.  He may struggle jamming NFL receivers on the line but as a backup corner for the Giants he would play off the line of scrimmage.  Johnson would compete for playing time at corner and probably makes the team as a fifth corner and special teams player.  If Johnson is not available, the team could select another corner of equal quality like Captain Munnerlyn of South Carolina.

 

Sixth Round: 27th pick (200th overall)

 

Stryker Sulak- DE 6’5” 250lbs. Missouri

Sulak was the most consistent pass rusher for the Tigers last season finishing the year with 10½ sacks and finishing his college career with 22½ sacks.  While Sulak lacks the bulk to consistently hold up against the run, he has the type of speed off the edge that you cannot teach.  He will have to work on disengaging from lineman in the pass rush, but he has the quick burst off the line of scrimmage to beat tackles around the edge.  The Giants do not necessarily need another DE but as GM Jerry Reese says you can never have enough pass rushers.  Sulak would compete for the 4th DE spot behind Osi Umenyiora, Justin Tuck, and Mathias Kiwanuka with Dave Tollefson.  Tollefson was not as good as expected in his second season and a strong preseason by Sulak could win him as roster spot.  The team could also target a RB, another LB, or a TE.

 

Seventh Round: 29th pick (238th overall)

 

Rodney Ferguson- RB 5’11” 238lbs. New Mexico

This is strictly a spot in the draft where you absolutely pick the best player available regardless of position, so I have about as much chance of guessing the player the team will pick as winning the lottery.  Ferguson is a big runner that has rushed for over 1,170 yards in all 3 of his seasons as a starter.  He has the ability to pick up needed yards in a goal line or short yardage situation.  He could fill the role as short yardage back taking away some of the pounding that Brandon Jacobs would receive.  He could also compete with Danny Ware as the 3rd RB on the roster.  The team could just as easily pick anyone at any position here, but I think Ferguson is a decent player that could be available here and add something to the team.

 

3/3/09

2009 Off-season Preview

 

Heading into the 2009 off season, the New York Giants are a very talented team with a few holes that would prevent them from being a serious contender in the 2009 season.  The biggest free agents that the team has are RB Derrick Ward, SS James Butler, and WR Amani Toomer.  The biggest holes that the team has to fill are at WR, DT, LB, and safety.  The team is in good position financially and draft wise to sign several free agents and draft picks to fill each area of need. 

 

Going, Going, Gone

 

1.      Derrick Ward- RB, 5’11” 228lbs.

Ward has the potential to be a starter, but would probably be better off as a #2 running back on a team with a marginal starter.  The team would love to have him back to continue being a second punch with starter Brandon Jacobs.  With the team already resigning Jacobs to a long term contract (4 years, $25 million), I seriously doubt Ward will be back.  He is a good running back that the team will not overspend to keep.  The team already has speedy Ahmad Bradshaw on its roster.  The team also has Danny Ware, whom impressed during the preseason and with limited carries in the regular season.  He is an exclusive rights free agent that the team should tender.  If they do not offer him a contract then RB becomes a priority in the draft.

 

2.      James Butler- SS, 6’3” 215lbs.

Butler has been a two year starter for the Giants with lots of big game experience, including starting the Super Bowl.  Butler has enough size, okay speed, and is a decent player.  He is adequate at stopping the run, but he has been out of position on some long TD runs.  Butler has the height and athleticism to also play the pass, but sometimes gets burned deep.  He is good enough to start but I think the team will part ways with him because they have two decent safeties in Kenny Philips and Michael Johnson that can start.  Johnson is nearly a clone of Butler is terms of size, speed, and ability.  Even though Butler made the calls for the defensive secondary, the team will turn that responsibility over to a new player like Philips, CBs Aaron Ross, or Corey Webster.  Butler will likely find a market that is not extremely hot on his abilities.

 

3.      Amani Toomer- WR, 6’3” 208 lbs.

Toomer will go down in team history as one of the best WRs ever to wear the Big Blue, but his skills are declining and other receivers on the roster are ready to take his spot.  Toomer still can be a good player in the slot, 4th receiver, or even as #2 on a team that really has little at WR.  Toomer years with the Giants should be commended and I hope that he and the team part on good terms.  He is a living Giants legend and all of the fans wish him nothing but the best in his future. 

 

No Place Like Home

 

1.      Brandon Jacobs- RB, 6’4” 264LBS.

The team franchise tagged and then was able to resign Jacobs to a 4-year deal making him one of the best paid RBs in the NFL.  Jacobs can be one of the best RBs in the league with his unique blend of size, speed, and power.  For the money the team paid to him, Jacobs has to find a way to remain in the lineup.  The team has solid change of pace backs, but no one that will be able to consistently match Jacobs’ production and what he offers.  Jacobs is the key cog in the potential playoff run for the 2009 Giants and beyond.

 

2.      David Carr- QB, 6’3” 216lbs.

Carr took the first step last season towards resurrecting his career as the backup to Eli Manning last season.  He has always had all of the skills that made him the #1 overall pick in the 2002 draft.  He has great size, a strong arm, accuracy, and the ability to make plays when a play has broken down.  However, getting sacked hundreds of times on the expansion Texans during his first seasons shattered his confidence.  Confidence is the key to any NFL quarterback.  Carr resigned an l year deal with the team to remain as backup.  This is good because it means the team is secure at QB in the 2009 season, but it also means the team should sign a #3 QB to develop into a future backup.  The team is not quite sold on the other QBs on the roster, like Andre Woodson or Anthony Wright.

 

3.      Kevin Dockery- CB, 5’8”, 188lbs

Dockery has shown that despite his height he is solid in coverage, okay against the run, and can start when needed.  The team tendered Dockery at a 2nd round level for a price tag of $1.5 million.  The team has been high on him because of his versatility.  He will play the nickel or dime CB position depending on how well Terrell Thomas develops.  With Dockery resigning the team is set at CB for next season with Thomas and Dockery as backups and Webster and Ross as the starters.

 

New Acquisitions

 

1.      Chris Canty- DE/DT, 6’7” 304LBS.

While I did feel that getting a defensive tackle in free agency or the draft was a priority, I did not expect them to be so aggressive in acquiring not one, but two.  I guess the fact that both Fred Robbins and Barry Cofield are in the last years of their contracts made this a big priority.  Canty has been a real thorn in the Giants side the past couple of seasons, when they have met.  Canty has excellent size, athleticism, and the ability to dominate a game.  He is still developing as a player being only 26, Canty (signed a 6year $42 million) will be a Giant during his prime years.  He likely fits as a starting defensive tackle relegating Fred Robbins to a backup role.  Robbins and other starter Barry Cofield wore down during last season showing the team that it needed an upgrade.  Coach Coughlin wanted Canty as a rookie coming out of Virginia and finally got him now. 

 

2.      Rocky Bernard- DT, 6’3” 308LBS.

Bernard has been a very good starter during the last couple of seasons for the Seahawks.  Bernard is a quick, athletic defensive tackle that can penetrate a pass protecting offensive line.  He made a lot of plays last season for the Seahawks finishing the year with 55 tackles and 4 sacks.  The team signed him to compete with Cofield for time at the other DT position.  His signing along with the signing of Canty mean that likely one of the teams DTs is expendable.  The signing of both DTs likely means that Robbins will be cut either before or during training camp.  He is 32 years old and scheduled to make $2 million this season.  This would mean that Canty and Cofield would start with Bernard seeing a lot of time and Jay Alford serving as the 4th DT. 

 

3.      Michael Boley- OLB, 6’3” 223lbs.

Last season the team got by with having Chase Blackburn as its weakside linebacker with Danny Clark as its strong side linebacker since Mathias Kiwanuka had to move up to defensive end with the injury to Osi Umenyiora.  Blackburn and Clark were okay, but the pass rush struggled with only Kiwanuka and Justin Tuck as pass rush threats.  The signing of the athletic Boley to start at weakside linebacker will cause a very positive ripple effect for the Giants defense.  Boley is very quick and good is pass coverage.  He has decent skills at stopping the run, but fell out of favor in Atlanta.  Boley should lock down WLB, allowing Kiwanuka to help at DE, and Clark and Blackburn to fight in training camp for the SLB position.  With Boley, Canty, Bernard, and the returning Umenyiora the team should have a potent pass defense package. 

 

Remaining Targets

 

1.      Wide Receiver- With the status of Plaxico Burress in the air and the departure of Toomer, the team has Steve Smith, Domenik Hixon, Mario Manningham, and David Tyree.  Smith and Hixon were basically starters at the end of last season, but they would be better as a #2 and slot receiver.  If Burress were to return as the #1 the team would be okay, but a big WR to eventually replace Burress is a need.  The free agent market at WR is thin with T.J. Houshmandzadeh being the best option.  Houshmandzadeh has some size but he is 31 years old, a year younger than Burress.  The draft is the best option for a wide receiver.  Lots of talented WRs with size are available but would not have much of an impact this season.  The Giant have the #29th overall pick in the first round and the #45 and the #60 overall picks in the second round.  The team should target a player like Kenny Britt (6’4” 215lbs.) of Rutgers, Darrius Heyward-Bey (6’3” 206lbs.) of Maryland, or Hakeem Nicks (6’1”, 210lbs.) of U.N.C. at one of these spots.

 

2.      Safety- The team has a set of decent starters in Phillips and Johnson, but no backups to mention with the likely departure of Butler and the cutting of Sammy Knight.  The team will likely target players in both the draft and free agency to find two new backups.  In free agency, a player like Atari Bigby from the Packers, C.C. Brown from the Texans, or George Wilson from the Bills would be a cheap backup that could start in a pinch and challenge Johnson for a starting spot.  In the draft, the team could target Patrick Chung of Oregon, Courtney Green of Rutgers, or Rashad Johnson of Alabama. 

 

I will be back in April with a draft preview.

 

image
image