3/18/04
Now that spring football is either
underway or about to get underway in college football it’s
time to take a look at the Big Ten Conference before the
competition begins. Ever spring players fight for their
spots, older players fight off younger ones, back-ups try to
become starters and guys step up to replace those departed
seniors that are trying to make the NFL. There seems to be
a theme to this year’s spring practices in the Big Ten,
Who’s your QB? There are only two teams going into the
spring that can claim that they know who their QB is for
sure. Purdue will fight for the top of the conference and
may have an edge with an experienced QB in Kyle Orton.
Indiana has stability as Matt LoVecchio returns as a starter
but that could be as much about a lack of competition as it
does about anything else. Let’s take a look around the
conference and see how the competitions shape up.
Ohio St.:
The top two QB’s from last season both graduated and now
it’s time for former big name recruit Justin Zwick to take
his place behind center. The only problem is that in two
years Zwick hasn’t played much and so far the hype is more
than the production. His competition for the spot comes in
the form of another talented sophomore named Troy Smith.
Smith hasn’t played either so there is no reason to assume
he’s better than Zwick. Zwick appears to have the upper
hand going into the spring but appearances and be
deceiving. This competition could prove very interesting.
Michigan:
Never to be outdone by the Buckeyes the graduation of John
Navarre has a QB controversy ready to explode. Last year’s
backup was Matt Gutierrez and while he never lost a game in
high school, this isn’t high school, and so far he hasn’t
played enough to convince anyone he’s Michigan’s next QB.
Last year’s blue-chip recruit was Clayton Richard from
Indiana and he has a year in the system now and is ready to
challenge Gutierrez in the spring. The real story in the
Michigan QB battle is that the winner of the spring
competition may not be the starter for long come fall. This
year’s blue-chip recruit is a kid named Chad Henne and he
could possibly be the most talented of the three and come
training camp he will likely push for playing time.
Penn St.: This may
not be as big of a competition as it is being made out to
be. Zack Mills has been the starter for a while but his was
hurt last season and super-athlete Michael Robinson stepped
in and showed flashes of brilliance. The problem is that in
the time Robinson has spent playing QB he has only shown
flashes. Mills has shown that when healthy and given some
weapons on offense he can be a very good QB. Crazy as it
may seem in this story one of Mills’ best offensive weapons
might be Michael Robinson if the coaching staff would put
him in a position and leave him there. This situation could
get even messier come fall because QB Anthony Morelli, one
the top recruits this past year has committed to Penn St.
and he could change everything in the fall.
Iowa: How about a
four-way competition between three sophomores and a
red-shirt freshman. Drew Tate came to Iowa last season and
in one training camp he rose to the backup position behind a
senior QB. Tate seems to have the inside track as Coach
Ferentz praised him last year as he came up the ranks.
However, third-year sophomores Jason Manson and Cy Phillips,
and red-shirt freshman Eric McCollum plan to give Kirk
Ferentz plenty to think about during the spring and they all
bring different talents to the table.
Illinois: This QB
competition comes courtesy of the NCAA. They granted Jon
Beutjer’s appeal for a sixth year of eligibility and even
though he was the starter last season and only lost it to an
injury with the way Illinois played last season I can’t
imagine that Ron Turner isn’t contemplating a change. Chris
Pazan was a freshman last year and while he was no Kurt
Kittner he wasn’t Beutjer either. Illinois was horrible
last season regardless of who was at the controls but Turner
has to have an open mind and go with whichever player gives
him the best chance to win. Another season like last year
and picking a QB for 2005 is going to become the problem of
someone else.
Wisconsin: Jim
Sorgi is gone and while he wasn’t the best QB to ever play
the game he was way ahead of his competition on the Badgers
last year. Matt Schabert will live in infamy for the rest
of his life for throwing the 79-yard TD to Lee Evans that
ended OSU’s winning streak but the rest of his season is
certainly forgettable. The problem for Barry Alvarez is
that John Stocco, while not playing horribly, didn’t exactly
light it up last year either. Coach Alvarez has to be
hoping that one of these two will mature and raise their
game this spring or he’s going to go into next year
contemplating running the wishbone with Anthony Davis,
Booker Stanley and Dwayne Smith.
Michigan St.: Now
that the Jeff Smoker Decade has ended it’s time for John L.
Smith to find the Spartans a new QB. The heir apparent is
Drew Stanton, he is young, talented and seems ready to take
over. One little problem is that Damon Dowdell has been
around awhile and sat behind Smoker and he isn’t likely to
just step out of the way. How much of a competition this
will be will depend on Stanton and how he takes to the
offense but I find it highly unlikely that Dowdell won’t at
least make him fight for the job.
Northwestern:
Competition may be overstating the situation. Bret Basanez
is not a terrible QB but he didn’t exactly put a
stranglehold on the job last season. Basanez’s biggest
competition is likely to come from incoming recruit CJ
Bacher. Bacher is the top recruit in the class and sure to
be a fan favorite (much like every other backup QB in the
country). While Bacher’s talent is certainly something to
look forward to the Wildcats will best be suited playing
their QB who has been through the rigors of the Big Ten.
Minnesota: The most wide-open
competition in the conference and it is not likely to be
settle until the five QB recruits Coach Mason has coming in
next fall arrive on campus. John Carlson is the most
heralded one of the recruits and the guys already on campus
don’t seem to be firing any one up. So come August Glen
Mason may have to put names on a dart board and blindfold
himself because replacing Asad Abdul-Khaliq looks like it
could be a challenge and unless someone proves they are up
to the challenge the Gophers offense will be Barber to the
left, Maroney to the right, Barber up the middle and punt.
2/10/04
Big Ten Column Recruiting
Wednesday,
February 4th, was signing day in college football
and a few teams in the Big Ten did very well, a few did
better than expected and some teams didn’t make much of a
splash at all. Let’s take a look from top to bottom.
Michigan:
22 players signed
The Good:
QB Chad Henne, WR’s Adrian Arrington and Doug Dutch, RB Max
Martin, OL’s Alan Branch and Brett Gallimore, LB Chris
Graham and DL Tim Jamison.
Henne is a 5-star QB recruit and with
John Navarre’s graduation Henne should be able to come in
and compete for playing time right away, which should make
Braylon Edwards happy. Branch, Gallimore, Arrington and
Dutch should add to a long legacy of OL and WR who have been
great at Michigan. Jamison was one of the most dominating
players at the U.S. Army All-American game and he could have
an immediate impact for the Wolverines.
The Bad: These guys
are Michigan recruits if they are bad we will never see them
because Michigan has other good players. If any of these 4
or 5-star recruits don’t pan out that could be bad but
Michigan can always get other 4 and 5-star recruits next
year to make it up.
Ohio St.: 23
players signed
The Good: CB Ted
Ginn, WR’s Albert Dukes and Devon Lyons, LB Marcus Freeman,
DL Vernon Gholston, TE’s Chad Hoobler and Rory Nicol, OL’s
Kyle Mitchum and Ben Person. CB Chris Gamble left OSU early
for the NFL Draft and CB University just grabbed the best
corner in the country, Ted Ginn, to be his replacement.
This kid should start from the day he sets foot on campus.
The other good news for Ohio St. is that in addition to
Mitchum and Person they also signed two other offensive
lineman in this class and considering the massive losses on
the OL this year this is a very good thing.
The Bad: Ohio St.’s
class is very good and the only thing I would be worried
about is that they signed one 4-star DL recruit, Vernon
Gholston, but only two other DL recruits even though they
lose three incredible starters off the DL this year. I’m
sure the Buckeyes have guys waiting in the wings but it
won’t be easy replacing Smith, Scott and Anderson.
Penn St.: 25
players signed
The Good: LB Dan
Connor, QB Anthony Morelli, OL Greg Harrison, DL A.Q.
Shipley. It’s not Michigan or Ohio St. but Connor and
Morelli are the kind of big names that JoPa has been losing
out on lately. As a matter of fact Morelli was verbally
committed to in-state rival Pitt before a falling out made
him reconsider and then he picked Penn St. Harrison and
Shipley are going to be very tough players in the trenches
for the Nittany Lions.
The Bad: I don’t
know if this class is enough to help JoPa turn things around
or not or if he will be there long enough to make it happen
but it is a step in the right direction and shows that
Paterno isn’t going to go without a fight.
Iowa: 20 players
signed
The Good: LB Kyle
Williams, CB Walner Belleus, OL’s Seth Olsen and Nyere
Aumaitre. Williams is the real deal and will likely
contribute immediately on the Hawkeyes defense, “The
Bonecrusher” as he is nicknamed has no intention of
redshirting and plans to play right away. Belleus is a JUCO
CB that is already on campus and will compete for playing
time starting with spring practice. Aumaitre and Olsen
along with little known Rashad Dunn are three offensive
lineman that will be molded by Kirk Ferentz and don’t be
surprised when they get drafted some day down the line.
The Bad: The
Hawkeyes went after a number of 5-star recruits this year
and with the exception of Kyle Williams they didn’t get any
of them. This is good and bad, it’s bad because they failed
to get them but it’s good because they coaching staff felt
secure enough with the players on hand that they didn’t have
to take just anyone they could get, Ferentz and Co. have
taken the Hawkeyes to a level where they only take the
diamonds in the rough they want and they can go after the
big boys they want.
Michigan St.: 30
players signed
The Good: WR’s
SirDarean Adams, Carl Grimes and Miles Williams, LB’s Hugh
D’Imperio and Dwayne Holmes, OL Roland Martin and DL Domata
Peko. This is a big class and the WR position looks well
taken care of as does the LB position. The Spartans have a
number of 4-star recruits in this class and it should add
depth throughout the roster.
The Bad: The
Spartans signed 30 players in this class but the NCAA rules
limit each class size to 25 players. I’ve only followed
recruiting for five of six years but in my experience that
usually means that the coaching staff expects some of these
players to not make the grades and they won’t be on campus
in the fall. If this happens to some of the top guys in
this class that could hurt the Spartans very much.
Purdue: 27 players
signed
The Good: WR’s
Dorien Bryant and Bruce Gordon, DL Jeremy Coley. Big class
by the numbers and the only thing that really sticks out
about the class is that the Boilermakers signed seven WR’s.
That seems like a lot of players at one position and I’ll go
out on a limb and guess not all of these guys will stay at
WR.
The Bad: Nothing
wrong with this class really, by position the class seems
balanced with the exception of so many receivers. Obviously
a couple of these guys may not qualify and that is why there
are 27 commitments.
Wisconsin: 23
players signed
The Good: DL Nick
Hayden. Hayden can be a player in the Big Ten. With the
loss of QB Jim Sorgi to graduation and they way the Badgers
looked without him last year it was imperative that they get
a QB and the Badgers signed QB’s Sean Lewis, Bryan Savage
and ATH Marcus Randel-El (yeah you read that name right).
Someone will have to step into that QB spot for the
Wisconsin to compete next year.
The Bad: Good class
for the Badgers just like normal. There are no absolute
stars like LSU and USC have but Wisconsin, like most teams
in the Big Ten, signed football players.
Minnesota: 24
players signed
I’m not going to get into
the good and bad on these last few teams, I’m just going to
point out some things I see. The Gophers signed 24 players,
six of which are listed at QB, it seems strange that a
quarter of a recruiting class would be at a position where
you only play one guy at a time. I’m guessing Coach Mason
has plans to move a few of these guys.
Illinois: 24
players signed
LB Sam Carson has to be the
headliner of this class because I don’t recognize to many of
the other names. After the season the Illini just had I
would think some of these players would have a chance to
compete for playing time right away.
Indiana: 24 players
WR’s James Bailey and Isaac
Price are probably the best of the class and that should
make Matt LoVecchio happy. The class is pretty well spread
out over the positions and that’s pretty good for the
Hoosiers.
Northwestern: 13
players signed
I know the Wildcats made a bowl game this year
but signing 13 recruits might be resting on their laurels
just a bit too much. Okay so it’s hard to recruit to a
school with higher academic standards and maybe the Wildcats
don’t have as many scholarships available this year, yeah
that has to be it, I’m giving them the benefit of the
doubt.
12/27/03
Now that the headache I had due to the
Bowl Confusion System is finally starting to subside I
thought I’d talk about the Big Ten teams and the bowl games
they will be playing in. Eight Big Ten teams were invited
to play in bowl games including the .500 Northwestern
Wildcats…membership has it’s privileges. I’m telling you if
Northwestern was in any other conference they would be
staying home this holiday season. I would like to thank the
BCS for giving us one and a half title games this year that
was quite nice of them. In case your confused (and I think
that’s what they were going for) the Sugar Bowl has two
teams playing for a National Title but the Rose Bowl only
has one team that could win a National Championship. (Only
in the world of the BCS)
Rose Bowl: Michigan vs. USC:
This game is completely unfair and I’m not talking about the
match-up, Michigan can hold their own. What’s unfair is the
fact the USC comes into this game gunning for a National
Title and Michigan doesn’t, who do you think has more to
play for in this game? Now like I said the Wolverines can
hold their own but I’ve seen USC play a few times this year
and they were the best team in the country at the end of the
season. The Trojans have a dynamic offense and a great
defense, I think Michigan has problems playing such an
athletic team that has so much more to play for. Even
though I’m a Big Ten guy I have to say that I’m rooting for
USC and LSU to win their games just to prove once in for all
that the BCS doesn’t work, the worst thing that could
happened would be for Oklahoma and Michigan to win which
would bail out the system. I hate the BCS, I hate the BCS,
I hate the BCS…sorry…sorry…won’t happen again.
Fiesta Bowl: Ohio St. vs.
Kansas St.: KSU has to be flying high after knocking off the
giants of college football the mighty Sooners. Oklahoma may
win a National Championship but the trophy will be lonely
because the Big 12 Championship is in Manhattan. The
luckiest team in America gets a chance to play in a BCS game
for the second straight year unfortunately they run into a
very confident K-St. team. Somehow I’m sure the Buckeyes
will win this game, but it will be ugly and probably lucky.
Capital One Bowl: Purdue vs.
Georgia: The Big Ten gets no breaks, the Bulldogs were
shellacked by LSU in the SEC title game and now an upset
Georgia team takes on a Purdue team that was not playing its
best ball at the end of the season. Purdue could light up
the scoreboard but Georgia has a very talented team and they
don’t want to end their season losing their last two
games.
Outback Bowl: Iowa vs.
Florida: The Hawkeyes have one of the best defenses in the
country. If they can put up some points on offense they
have a great chance to win this game. Iowa should be almost
completely healthy for the first time all season long. The
Gators are a tough, fast team but the Hawkeyes can beat
them.
Alamo Bowl: Michigan St. vs.
Nebraska: Okay so maybe the Big Ten gets one break.
Playing a team that just fired their coach and having their
interim coach looking for jobs on different staffs certainly
has to give the Spartans some confidence against Nebraska.
Michigan St. slid a little at the end of the season but the
Cornhuskers may be just the remedy for the Spartans.
Sun Bowl: Minnesota vs.
Oregon: The Gophers don’t travel well so they ended up at
the Sun Bowl instead of the Alamo Bowl and their prize was a
chance to play the Oregon Ducks a team that beat the Big Ten
Champion Michigan Wolverines. Good Luck to Glen and the
boys you may need it.
Music City Bowl: Wisconsin vs.
Auburn: No one is doing the Big Ten any favors. The
seventh place team gets to play Auburn in Memphis, I know
Auburn has struggled at times this year but having to play a
team with Cadillac Williams and LB’s Karlos Dansby and
Dontarrious Thomas is just simply unfair. This should be a
great game where both teams run all day long.
Motor
City Bowl:
Northwestern vs. Bowling Green: AKA the “We saved Randy
Walker’s Job” Bowl. These two teams get to travel to
Detroit and play at Ford Field. Amazing that the city of
Detroit built a stadium just to host a bowl game, seems like
a waste maybe the city should look into getting an NFL
team. I hear the former 49ers coach lives in the area maybe
they could get him to coach them…just a thought.
12/5/03
Someone help
me the BCS is holding the Big Ten hostage until they decide
if they want Ohio St. or not. This means Purdue, Iowa and
Minnesota have to wait to see which bowls they go to this
year. The Capital One Bowl, the Outback Bowl and the Alamo
Bowl are waiting for the dominos to fall so they can set
their match-ups. If Ohio St. gets in…when Ohio St. gets
in…then the politics start to get involved. The Capital One
Bowl gets first choice and while Purdue beat Iowa and
finished 6-2 in the conference to Iowa’s 5-3 record the
Capital One reps are having a hard time ignoring the almost
50,000 fans Iowa took to Florida for the Orange Bowl last
year. Since both Purdue and Iowa finished 9-3 overall the
Capital One Bowl gets to choose, they could also take
Minnesota at 9-3 but the Gophers can dream on. When it
comes to Bowl games money talks and no one should be shocked
if Iowa goes to the Capital One Bowl and Purdue goes to the
Outback Bowl this wouldn’t be the first time or the last
time that money sets a bowl match-up.
My defensive top 5
prospects include three underclassmen, two of which I
believe will come out this year and one that might but I
think will return to school.
1. Chris Gamble CB Ohio
St.
This guy hasn’t even been a
full-time corner for his whole career and he could be the
first corner taken in this draft and the scary thing is this
is a good class of corners. His size and athletic ability
are first rate and he is only going to get better, he is
only a junior and he could return but I don’t expect him
too.
2. Marlin Jackson CB
Michigan
He’s been playing safety at
Michigan all year because that’s where they needed him but I
suspect he will play corner in the pros. He has size and
range and he has proven he can hit like a safety and having
that experience isn’t going to hurt his stock. He is also a
junior and I would say that the Wolverines might as well say
their goodbyes at the Rose Bowl.
3. Will Smith DE Ohio
St.
An undersized but fast DE,
where have I heard that before? Oh yeah, Dwight Freeney,
Javon Kearse, okay so Smith isn’t in that class but the
success of guys like that means that teams will give Smith a
chance and that’s all he will need.
4. Antajj Hawthorne DT
Wisconsin
This guy is a Junior and I
doubt there is a guy that opposing coaches are hoping leaves
more than him. Hawthorne is dominating and he is just
getting started, I think he will return to Wisconsin for his
senior year but no one would blame him if he left. To the
average fan he isn’t the name that Vince Wilfork or Tommie
Harris is but he’s got the attention of pro scouts.
5. Stuart Schweigert S
Purdue
I think this guy has been
starting at Purdue since the Bush administration, the first
one. He doesn’t wow people most of the time but he is smart
and tough and talented and has started for four years in the
Big Ten. He Can Play. And he will play on Sundays for a
long time.
5a. Bob Sanders S Iowa
As a prospect goes most teams will think he
isn’t tall enough to be drafted high. If he was 6’3 instead
of 5’8 he’d be taken in the first 15 picks. No matter where
he is drafted he will be the steal of the draft. He was the
biggest on the field reason for the turnaround at Iowa, no
one has made a bigger impact on a team than him. He sets
the tone and he will do it in the pros.
11/21/03
Players of the Week:
Offense: WR Lee Evans Wisconsin
Defense: S Bob Sanders Iowa
Co-Special Teams: K Nate Kaeding
Iowa
P BJ Sander
Ohio St.
So it all comes down to this,
Ohio St. at Michigan for the Big Ten title. A BCS birth is on
the line and bowl positioning will be decided by the games this
weekend. If Ohio St. wins then they will be headed to the Sugar
Bowl barring some strange computer glitch and when it comes to
the BCS I rule nothing out. This would set up Ohio St.’s chance
to defend their National Championship against presumably the
Oklahoma Sooners. Now as much as I love the Big Ten I can tell
you that if Ohio St. has to play Oklahoma it won’t be much of a
National Championship game…think Nebraska vs. Miami a few years
ago except it won’t be that close. If Michigan wins this will
make the Rose Bowl very happy because they would get Michigan
and even if USC goes onto the Sugar Bowl the Rose Bowl may have
a chance to pick Washington St. and set up the Big Ten/Pac-Ten
match-up they want. If Ohio St wins then the Rose Bowl ends up
with USC vs. someone not from the Big Ten. Now of course this
is all dependant on other teams from other conferences doing
what they need to do so just a warning…ALL SCENARIOS ARE SUBJECT
TO CHANGE.
Purdue, Michigan St., Wisconsin
and Iowa are the teams playing for positioning in the bowl
picture for the Big Ten. Iowa and Wisconsin play each other so
that will be the big game outside of Michigan/Ohio St. Purdue
plays Indiana and Michigan St. plays Penn St. so they have the
easier time. Northwestern is playing to get to .500 overall and
in conference and bowl eligible but even if they do they would
have to get an at-large bid to a bowl because the Big Ten has
seven bowl tie-ins and Northwestern would be the eighth team.
Once the bowl picture clears up after next week and beyond I
will update you.
This is my list of the top five offensive
prospects for the 2004 draft out of the Big Ten. I didn’t
include Braylon Edwards because he says he’s staying in school
and might I say smart move Braylon.
1. Robert Gallery OT Iowa :
Gallery is one of the top
prospects overall in the country and is likely to be a top ten
pick. He’s 6-7 320 lbs. and he moves like a man half that
size. One of the most dominating blockers in college football
and is equally adept at run blocking and pass blocking. Has
very few flaws and plays with the aggressiveness you like to see
in an offensive lineman.
2. Michael Jenkins WR Ohio St.:
You can’t teach a guy to be 6-5
215 lbs and be able to run like Jenkins. His weaknesses are the
things coaches can correct…he can be a better route runner and
down field blocker and his production should be better once he
is in the pros and playing with better talent. A quarterback
who and get him the ball in a position to make plays and another
receiver who can take some defensive attention away from him and
he can be a dynamic offensive player.
3. Lee Evans WR Wisconsin:
He isn’t the tallest or the
fastest wide receiver but the kid makes plays. He was the
offensive player of the week in the Big Ten and that is an
understatement. Ten catches for 258 yards and 5 TD’s is off the
charts. If you want a WR who will make a difference here he
is…oh and that knee injury he had…what knee injury?
4. Nate Kaeding K Iowa:
Stop laughing this is no joke.
You want an offensive weapon? Kaeding kicked a 55-yard field
goal last week against Minnesota and it would have been good
from 65 yards. How about field position? He routinely puts his
kickoffs through the end zone and once in awhile through the
uprights. Any good team in the NFL that only has questions in
their kicking game will take a long hard look and how can you
not love a kicker that wears shoulder pads that are 2 sizes too
big and the number 95.
5. Tony Pape OT Michigan:
What can I say, he is a
Michigan offensive lineman its like being a WR from Florida St.
or CB from Ohio St. Jon Runyan, Jeff Backus, Jon Jansen…all
lineman who start in the NFL, do a good solid job and nobody has
ever heard of them. Tony Pape fits that mold, draft him play
him and forget about the position for ten years because it’s
been taken care of. Pape is not in the class of Robert Gallery
or Shawn Andrews but someone is going to get a damn good
offensive lineman.
NEXT
WEEK: Defensive Prospects.